SEO courseModule 9 of 10: Playing it smartLesson 9.2
Your competitors, and the searches you can win
Who you’re actually up against for each search (portals, national chains, local rivals, directories), where they’re weak, and which searches a local agency can realistically win.
By Morgan King, founder of Reyse. Facts checked October 2026. Jump to Your turn
Why it matters
People choose between you and the specific rival they also found.
Why Google cares
Evidence: Common sense
Rankings are relative to the competition
Do this first
Pick three rivals and ten searches, and note where each rival is weak.
What it is
How fast you need to run at sports day depends on who else is in the race.
Think of it like
Opening a corner shop next to a huge supermarket is harder than opening one on a quiet street, even if both shops are just as good.
Why it matters to the people searching
People aren’t choosing “a good agent” in the abstract. They’re choosing between you and the specific rival they also found, so being better than that one business is what wins.
buyers
Mostly see portals for broad searches; you win them on specific local searches the portals handle badly.
tenants
Same: “2 bed flat to rent near [station]” is more winnable than “flats to rent [city]”.
sellers
Compare you with local rivals, national chains and online agents.
landlords
Same, and compare fees and management promises side by side.
To Google and Bing
Evidence: Common senseA page never ranks in isolation: your position depends on how strong the alternatives are. Improving your site always helps, but for some searches the smart move is a narrower one you can actually win. “Letting agents Didsbury” is often within reach when “estate agents Manchester” is owned by portals and chains.
The evidence: Rankings are relative to the competition, so choosing winnable searches is practical strategy.
An agent example
An independent agency can’t beat the portals for “houses for sale Manchester”, but finds that “houses for sale Chorlton” shows weak, generic pages from two chains. It builds a genuinely useful Chorlton page with local data and its own listings, and wins it within a few months.
Your turn: check yours, then fix it
- 1In a private window, search 10 target phrases across your four audiences.
- 2For each, record who’s in the top 10 (portal, chain, local agency, directory) and what kind of page ranks.
- 1Pick competitors you genuinely lose business to.
- 2Use this course as a checklist on their site: pages for each audience, reviews, Business Profile, content depth, speed.
- 3Check their link strength with Ahrefs’ free tools.
- 4Check what they’ve set up underneath: put their homepage into Google’s Rich Results Test to see their schema (lesson 2.6), and add /robots.txt to the end of their web address to see whether they let AI tools in (GEO 3.1).
- 5Note where they’re clearly stronger, and where they’re weaker.
- 1Run your five most important searches on Bing and in Apple Maps too, and note who appears. Apple Maps is the iPhone’s built-in map app, and Edge on Windows searches with Bing unless someone changes it.
- 2Ask ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google’s AI Mode who they’d recommend in your area, and note who’s named.
Here is the text of my homepage and a key page, and the same from my competitor’s site. What are they covering that I’m not, and where am I already ahead? Which of these searches look winnable for a small local agency: [list]?
- 1Target specific areas, property types and questions before the biggest city-wide searches.
- 2Fix the gap that’s easiest for you and hardest for them to copy: real local data, named expertise, a relationship they don’t have.
- 1Re-run the comparison every quarter. Competitors don’t stand still either.
- 2Keep it on one sheet: a row for each check (your 10 searches, Bing and Apple, the AI answers, and the review numbers from Reviews 5.3) and a column for each quarter.
- 3Set a free Google Alert for each rival’s name, so a new office, press story or award reaches you without searching.
- 4Act when something moves the same way in two checks running. A single change is usually noise: rankings and AI answers wobble on their own.
Rather we did this for you? It’s part of Found First.
Keep it up
This goes stale the moment it’s filed away. Revisit it quarterly.
Sources
- 1.SEO Starter Guide, Google Search Central
- 2.Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content, Google Search Central
Facts checked October 2026, and re-checked every quarter. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.
Worked through it? Mark it done and we’ll keep track on this device.
Back to 9.1 Shortcuts that get you penalised, and how to choose an SEO provider