Review Management courseModule 4 of 7: Every platform that countsLesson 4.1
Claiming and running your Google reviews
Your Google Business Profile is the listing that appears when someone looks you up on Google Search or Maps, and it carries your Google reviews. Claiming it means taking control of it; verifying it means proving to Google it’s yours; running it means someone checks it every week. If it isn’t claimed and verified, you can’t reply to a single review on it.
By Morgan King, founder of Reyse. Facts checked October 2026. Jump to Your turn
Why it matters
Profiles set up years ago on a former employee’s personal Gmail, with nobody able to reply and reviews piling up unanswered.
The evidence
Evidence: Official guidance
Google’s own help pages for the mechanics, the rules and reviews helping local ranking. The ranking order is an expert survey, not Google data.
Do this first
Sign in at business.google.com and check who owns each branch’s profile, and whether you can reply.
What it is
Imagine a noticeboard at the school gate where parents write what they think of the after-school club. If the club leader has no key and never looks at it, parents decide nobody cares. Claiming is getting the key. Running it is reading the board every week.
Think of it like
The shop window on the high street. Most people see it before they ever step inside, and a dusty, dated window says more than any leaflet.
Why it matters to the people searching
For most people, Google reviews are the first reviews they see, often before they’ve opened your website. In YouGov’s 2025 survey, 45% of British adults said they use Google reviews when checking an unfamiliar business. UK evidence on agents is thinner: in a 2017 HomeOwners Alliance survey only 19% of sellers had looked up reviews of their agent. Treat your Google reviews as something the next seller or landlord may well check, not something every one of them will.
buyers
See your rating, recent reviews and replies on Google or Maps, often before your site.
tenants
Look up the agent holding their deposit, usually after finding the property.
sellers
Compare ratings, recency and how you handled complaints before inviting you to value.
landlords
Look for rent collection, repairs and communication, and how you reply when things go wrong.
To Google, the platforms and AI
Evidence: Official guidanceGoogle says local results depend partly on prominence, which includes how many reviews you have, and that more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking. There’s no way to pay for a better ranking, and no target rating, count or reply time. In Whitespark’s 2026 survey of 47 local search experts (US and Canada centred), a high Google rating ranked 6th of 187 factors for the map results, the number of reviews with text 9th, recency 11th and a steady flow 14th, while replying to most reviews ranked 122nd. Google also shows AI-written review summaries in some places (“Summarized with Gemini”), including in the UK. Businesses can’t write them; only real reviews change them.
- a high Google rating, of 187 local ranking factors (Whitespark 2026)
- 6tha high Google rating, of 187 local ranking factors (Whitespark 2026)
- replying to most reviews
- 122ndreplying to most reviews
An agent example
A lettings branch of Larchwyn Lettings had a profile set up years earlier by a former office junior on a personal Gmail. Nobody could reply, and 12 reviews sat unanswered, the newest five months old. The manager got access through Google’s verification steps, made a head-office account the owner, added a second manager, and blocked out 15 minutes every Monday. Within a month every review had a reply.
Your turn: check yours, then fix it
- 1Sign in at business.google.com with the account you think owns the profile.
- 2Can you see Read reviews and a reply option? If not, the profile is unclaimed, unverified or owned by someone else. Write down who.
- 1In a private window, search each branch name and town on Google and on Google Maps.
- 2Check there’s exactly one profile per branch. Note the rating, review count, newest review date and how many of the latest 20 have a reply.
- 1List everyone with access to each branch profile, and their role.
- 2Are any of them former staff, personal Gmail accounts or an old web supplier? Is the Primary Owner a company account?
Here are my last 20 Google reviews and my replies, with all names, addresses and staff names removed. Which reviews have no reply? Which replies are generic? Which reviews might break Google’s review policy? Don’t guess beyond the text.
- 1Claim and verify the profile at business.google.com, following Google’s on-screen steps. The verification options vary.
- 2If a profile already exists, claim that one. Never create a second profile for the same branch: reviews stay with the original.
- 3Created a duplicate by mistake? Contact Google to move the reviews. If two profiles are merged, reviews combine but replies can be lost, so copy your replies first.
- 1Make a company-controlled Google account the Primary Owner, never a negotiator’s personal Gmail.
- 2Add at least one other manager, give branch staff only the access they need, and remove leavers the same day.
- 3For a group or franchise, agree in writing who owns each branch profile, and make sure head office never creates a second one.
- 4Don’t create a new profile when a branch moves or rebrands: Google says reviews move with the same profile when the name stays the same.
- 1Read any new reviews and reply to every one without a reply, oldest first (lesson 3.1).
- 2Look for reviews that break Google’s policy (lesson 3.3).
- 3Note the date of the newest review.
- 4Confirm opening hours, phone number and photos are current.
- 1Google bans reviews paid for in money or in kind, several reviews from one person, and reviews from staff, former staff, contractors, competitors and family.
- 2It also bans asking only for positive reviews, discouraging negative ones and, since April 2026, asking staff to collect a set number of reviews or reviews that name them.
- 3Asking every customer for an honest review, with nothing in return, is allowed.
Then: Turn on notifications too (lesson 5.1), so you hear about reviews as they land, not just on check day.
Rather we did this for you? It’s part of Found First.
Keep it up
Weekly, at minimum. This is usually your busiest review platform, so it earns the most attention.
Go deeperMissing, vanished or wrong-profile reviews
- A client says they left a review and you can’t see it: ask them to check they’re signed in to the right Google Account and look under Your contributions. Check it isn’t on another branch. Google’s automated checks can hold reviews for a while.
- A review has disappeared: the reviewer may have edited or deleted it, Google may have removed it for a policy breach, or its spam filter may have caught a genuine one by mistake (contact Google support if so).
- Reviews on the wrong profile: look for a duplicate, an old address or a closed branch, and check your review link comes from the right branch.
- Never try to replace missing reviews by asking staff, family or friends to post.
Go deeperAsk Maps and AI summaries
Google launched Ask Maps, a Gemini chat in Google Maps that draws on reviews, in March 2026 in the US and India. As of October 2026 it wasn’t confirmed for the UK. Check on a UK phone from time to time. The only way to influence what these features say is the reviews themselves, and the service behind them.
Sources
- 1.How UK shoppers check if an online store is legit before purchasing, YouGov, 2025
- 2.Consumers fail to check facts and figures when appointing estate agents, HomeOwners Alliance, September 2017
- 3.Tips to improve your local ranking on Google, Google Business Profile Help
- 4.Local Search Ranking Factors 2026, Whitespark, 2026
- 5.Prohibited and restricted content, Google Maps user contributed content policy
Facts checked October 2026, and re-checked every quarter. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.
Worked through it? Mark it done and we’ll keep track on this device.
Back to 3.3 Fake, unfair and defamatory reviews: reporting, removal and legal options