Review Management courseModule 3 of 7: ReplyingLesson 3.1
Replying to every review, within hours
A genuine, specific reply to every review, five-star ones included, written within hours rather than weeks. Two habits: reply to all, and reply fast.
By Morgan King, founder of Reyse. Facts checked October 2026. Jump to Your turn
Why it matters
Most reviews never get a reply, especially the five-star ones, and a reply that arrives weeks later reads as nobody caring.
The evidence
Evidence: Study
The benefit of replying comes from US surveys and hotel studies, not UK agents. Google’s guidance covers how to reply, with no ranking claim. Same-day replies are our recommended practice.
Do this first
Count how many of your last 20 reviews have a reply, then clear the backlog, oldest first.
What it is
If a friend gives you a present and you say “thank you, I love the blue one”, they feel noticed. If you never say anything, even a good present starts to feel wasted. A shop that answers everyone in the queue looks like it’s listening.
Think of it like
Answering the door. Answer quickly and kindly, and visitors relax. Answer a week later, and it doesn’t matter how nice you are.
Build a reply, and watch the check underneath react to every part you add.
Build the reply
- !Thanks them by name
- !Specific, not copy-and-paste
- ✓No personal details or amounts
- ✓No offers
- !Signed by a real person
Hannah R. ★★★★★
Sold our flat in six weeks. Ellie kept us updated every step.
Response from the owner
Thanks for your kind review!
Not ready yet: fix the red items first.
Why it matters to the people searching
The next seller, landlord, tenant or buyer reads your reply as well as the review. A reply to a five-star review is visible proof that someone’s paying attention. Speed reads as care: a reply after the frustration has settled into resentment rarely lands the same way. In BrightLocal’s 2026 survey (1,002 US adults), 80% said they’d be more likely to use a business that replies to all its reviews, and half were put off by templated replies.
buyers
Read replies to judge how you treat people when things go wrong.
tenants
Look for whether anyone’s listening, especially on repairs and deposits.
sellers
Read replies to judge whether you’re accountable.
landlords
Often read your replies to complaints before the reviews themselves.
To Google, the platforms and AI
Evidence: StudyReplying isn’t a confirmed ranking factor. Google says positive reviews and helpful replies can help your business stand out, which is about people, not ranking. In Whitespark’s 2026 survey of 47 local search experts, replying to most reviews ranked 122nd of 187 factors, and keywords in replies 182nd, so stuffing replies with town names isn’t worth it. Google checks replies against its content policy before they appear (usually within 10 minutes, sometimes up to 30 days), tells the reviewer you replied, and lets them edit their review afterwards, which updates its date.
- of 5-star Google reviews get a reply (UENI, 229,882 reviews)
- 29%of 5-star Google reviews get a reply (UENI, 229,882 reviews)
- of 1-star reviews get one
- 10%of 1-star reviews get one
An agent example
Silverdune Estates had 64 Google reviews and 11 replies, almost all to complaints. On a Friday afternoon the manager cleared the backlog oldest to newest, with a sentence naming something specific in each. She made the lettings assistant owner of replies, with the sales administrator as deputy, and set a 10-minute slot each morning. A month later, most replies were going out the same day.
Your turn: check yours, then fix it
- 1Open your Business Profile and go to Read reviews.
- 2Count how many of your last 20 reviews have a reply. Note how many unanswered ones are five-star: that’s usually where the gap is.
- 1For your last 10 replies, compare the date the review was posted with the date of your reply.
- 2Are negative reviews answered faster or slower than positive ones?
- 1Read your last five replies as if you were deciding whether to trust you.
- 2Do they mention something specific, or could they sit under any review unchanged? Search for repeated phrases.
- Read the same replies for personal data, fee or rent amounts, deposit details, reference numbers, allegations or offers. Edit out anything like that.
Here are 10 anonymised replies from an estate agency. Which sound copy-and-pasted? Which contain personal or confidential information? Which could be warmer or more specific? Don’t rewrite them yet.
- 1Oldest to newest, short and specific. Don’t let it build up again.
- 2On Google: Read reviews, the reply icon, type your reply, then Reply. To change it later, choose Edit.
- 1Five stars: “Thank you, [first name]. I’m glad the move went smoothly, and I’ll pass your kind words to [colleague] in the lettings team. We wish you well in the new home. [Your first name], [branch]”
- 2Mixed: “Thank you for the feedback, [first name]. I’m pleased [good point]. I’m sorry [problem] wasn’t as it should be, and we’re looking at it this week. If you’d like to talk it through, please call [name] on [branch number].”
- 3Vary your wording. If every reply says “Thank you for your kind review”, readers notice.
- 1Never include addresses, reference numbers, rent or fee amounts, deposit details, or anything about a tenant or landlord the reviewer hasn’t said publicly.
- 2On a negative review, avoid confirming they were your client. The Property Ombudsman’s lettings code says client information may only be used for the purpose it was given.
- 3Leave out allegations, legal wording, offers and arguments about the facts.
- 1Turn on notifications to a shared inbox (lesson 1.3), so reviews reach you when they’re posted.
- 2Give one named person ownership of replies, with a deputy for holidays. Unclear ownership is usually why replies slip.
- 3Aim for a reply within a few working hours, and by the next morning at the latest. If you can’t answer properly yet, post a short holding reply the same day (lesson 3.2).
- Edit it so it sounds like you, and post it yourself. Never let a tool post replies automatically.
Draft a three-sentence UK-English reply to this review for an estate agency. Thank them, mention one specific point from the review, include no personal data, offer nothing, and don’t argue. [paste anonymised review text]
Then: Check your average reply time each month. A fast, poor reply is worse than a slightly later good one.
Rather we did this for you? It’s part of Found First.
Keep it up
Daily, or at least a few times a week. A month’s backlog is a much bigger job than staying on top of it.
Go deeperDoes replying to everything really help?
A peer-reviewed study of TripAdvisor hotels (Proserpio and Zervas, 2017) found hotels that started replying received about 12% more reviews and a rating about 0.12 stars higher on average. But a Cornell hotel study (2016) found the gains levelled off at around a 40% reply rate and warned that many poor replies can be worse than none. Neither is about UK agents. Our reading: quality matters more than volume, so reply to everything only if every reply is specific.
You’ll see a claim that 89% of consumers are more likely to choose a business that replies to every review, and that a reviewer is three times more likely to update their rating if you reply within four hours. We couldn’t trace either to a study, so this course doesn’t rely on them.
See also
Sources
- 1.Local Consumer Review Survey 2026, BrightLocal, 2026
- 2.Local Search Ranking Factors 2026, Whitespark, 2026
- 3.Google review response study, UENI, 2026
- 4.Codes of practice, The Property Ombudsman
Facts checked October 2026, and re-checked every quarter. Spotted something out of date? Tell us.
Worked through it? Mark it done and we’ll keep track on this device.
Back to 2.4 Ask everyone, lawfully: privacy, consent and your team